@christianbeamz6774
That last story felt more like a relationship therapy session than a scary story
@FireDaemon13
The guy in the last story didn’t even tell the police that they were robbed. Through the entire story, honestly revealed more about his character than Amanda. I can just tell that break up was messy.
@regularphill
That first story reminded me of a time I broke into someone's house made some coffee and took all the knives! Small world!
@Jayden-lr2mm
What was scary about the last story was that Bella despite her drunken state opened the door to a burglar, and that everyone in the party was too oblivious since they were all drunk as well
@Parkour_Kingdom
Every time this man uploads my day gets better.
@a_ghostnamed_Anna
1:30 skinny dipping at your own house is hardly devious
@Lawrence_Talbot
The knives being gone means you cannot defend yourself. He took away any chance of having a weapon. The cops did nothing. The locks did nothing. You are not safe inside your house.
@ATC_b
The guy in the last story literally could not have handled the situation any worse.
@TrueImmortality
The last guy is definitely the actual narcissist in the relationship lol. The only person he liked in a family was the dad, he described his girlfriend in such unflattering terms, and he goes on about how charming he is lmao
@itsbecky_13
The way the first guy was so nonchalant about the entire thing 😭
@LonelyStar831
I've never hated anyone whose stories told on this channel as much as that guy in the 3rd story, and I'm glad I'm not alone.
@pamalawashington9371
I wonder why the dude in the last story didn't tell the police that the house had been robbed. There may have still been an opportunity to catch the dude, since it had just happened. Amanda may not have been innocent in their relationship, but this wasnt a good move on his part.
@Geraldwatkin
Last story was hard to follow I think he cared more about flaunting himself and his beliefs than the actual story…..
@everthpalmer5017
The guy in the last story definitely got broken up with 😬
@Iloveeggs140
Last story guy pissed me off so bad that i had to come look for hate comments about him and was very happy to see a whole topic about it
@marcii6103
i can’t listen to other scary stories like i do when mr. nightmare reads them, his voice and the tones he’s reads them in is what makes the stories seem so real i can imagine everything in my head like im there
@carson3525
Just passed all my finals and Mr. nightmare posted… Life is good rn!
@RuminatingRaptor
That last dude was the horror story.
@jeffreylamonica7448
Worst Police Search of a House EVER!
@tbone-experience